Title:
Rare Autograph Letter Signed (ALS) Thrice by Millard Fillmore – Buffalo, November 2, 1835 – PSA/DNA Certified (AR02767)

Description:
Exceptionally rare handwritten legal letter signed three times by Millard Fillmore, dated “Buffalo Nov. 2nd 1835,” written on folded, lined paper and addressed on the integral leaf to “N. Hubbard Esq., Sup. Court Clerk, Utica.” The document features Fillmore’s handwriting throughout and concludes with a prominent “M. Fillmore” signature, along with two additional instances of his signature/handwritten name on the address panel and docketing, making this a highly desirable triple-signed example.

Triple-signed Fillmore documents are notably scarce, particularly in early legal correspondence from his pre-presidential period. Most surviving examples feature a single signature; instances with multiple signatures—especially three—are seldom encountered and significantly enhance both rarity and collector appeal.

The letter exhibits typical age-related wear, including fold lines, light toning, and a small loss at the lower left affecting minor portions of text but not the primary signature. The address panel remains intact with a visible postal marking.

Full Transcription:

“Buffalo Nov. 2nd 1835

N. Hubbard Esq.
Sup. Court Clerk

Sir

Please to search and send me a certificate of all judgments & decrees in equity against the following persons for the following times, and note the amount and charge the same to Fillmore + Keall(?) please.

Oliver G. Steele – 10 years last past
Rushmore Poole – The like
William H. Lacy – from Nov. 1, 1825 to Nov. 29, 1835
Hiram Chittenden – from Nov. 1, 1825 to March 4, 1834
Martin Chittenden – same as last
Philander Bennett – from Nov. 1, 1825 to March 4, 1832
William Williams – same as last
David E. Evans – from Nov. 1, 1825 to Dec. 4, 1827 all inclusive.

You will do me a great favor to let me have it as soon as possible.

Respectfully Yours
M. Fillmore

Fees $9.50 done Nov 5 1835
(30 Judgts)”

Historical Context:
This rare legal letter originates from Millard Fillmore’s early career as a practicing attorney in Buffalo, New York, well before his presidency as the 13th President of the United States (1850–1853). Born in 1800, Fillmore rose from modest beginnings to become a respected lawyer and political figure in western New York.

The content reflects routine but essential legal work of the era—requesting certified records of judgments and equity decrees—highlighting the manual and detail-oriented nature of 19th-century legal practice. Attorneys like Fillmore depended heavily on court clerks and handwritten correspondence to obtain official records necessary for litigation and financial claims.

This document provides a valuable glimpse into Fillmore’s professional life during a formative period when he balanced legal practice with his early political career. Such letters are increasingly scarce, particularly those retaining full content and multiple signatures.

Authentication & Encapsulation:
Accompanied by a PSA/DNA Letter of Authenticity (Certification No. AR02767), confirming the authenticity of the signatures attributed to “Millard Fillmore (Triple).” The certification verifies that all signature examples on the document are consistent with known authentic specimens.

• Additional Documentation & Provenance: At buyer’s request, Historical Autographs Gallery will include an additional “Historical Autographs Gallery Certificate” signed by our company founder Luke Pascal at no cost.

Closing Appeal:
A rare and highly collectible triple-signed legal ALS from Millard Fillmore’s early career, combining strong historical content with exceptional autograph rarity. The presence of three distinct Fillmore signatures—an uncommon feature seldom seen in the marketplace—elevates this piece well above standard examples. For collectors of presidential autographs and early American legal history, this document represents a scarce and compelling acquisition.

Shipping Notice:
For insurance purposes, items sold over $600 may require signature confirmation upon delivery. Higher-value items, likely over $1,500, are shipped via FedEx 2-Day with Direct Signature Confirmation. FedEx provides the most flexibility when requiring a signature, allowing you to make special delivery requests directly through their tracking system. This ensures both security and convenience for the buyer.